Addressing Healthcare Market Imbalance
The NHN was established as a response to the competition imbalance between the independent private hospital market on the one hand, and the 3 (three) large hospital groups on the other. Historically privileged entrepreneurs joined hands with their historically disadvantaged black counterparts and formed the NHN as a public company in 1996, when most of the discriminatory laws which were used to exclude a large majority of the black population from participating in the economy of the country were still in place.
In fact, the founding members emerged during a period marked by the economic exclusion and exploitation of black people, most of whom were relegated to abject poverty. Most commercial banks and financial institutions implemented fragmented, racially based business- support policies and programmes which had a particular impact on most businesses at the time – most of which were the majority of small and medium micro enterprises owned and controlled by historically disadvantaged persons which were subjected to financial and commercial secrecy which epitomised the apartheid state.
Coincidentally, the formation of the NHN coincided with the adoption of the final Constitution of South Africa in 1996. The aim of the NHN was for independent private hospitals to coordinate efforts at opening up the private hospital economy to previously excluded groups in order to mitigate the high concentration which was embedded in the big 3 (three) hospital groups for the longest time.
At the time of its formation in 1996, a majority of the independent private healthcare members of the NHN could not effectively and individually compete against the 3 (three) large hospital groups which, by then, had already established and positioned themselves to provide services in a multitude of healthcare disciplines. One of the advantages enjoyed by all the 3 (three) big hospital groups is the greater national geographical footprint, especially acute hospital beds which the NHN does not enjoy.
Despite that the Competition Act had not been promulgated at the time, the winds of change had signalled the dawn of a competition regime which would foster economic inclusion. As if prophetic, the NHN entrenched economic inclusion as one of its primary objectives in its Memorandum of Incorporation (‘NHN MOI’). This objective is one of the pillars of the Competition Act which was promulgated 2 (two) years later in 1998.
More than a decade later in 2007 the NHN was incorporated as a non-profit company and, since then, its flagship has been to serve as a competitive counterbalance to the 3 (three) large hospital groups which by then had long solidified their market strength. What is more, the NHN also promotes the interests of its members, markets their services and provides a base for benchmarking, which not only assists NHN members to increase efficiencies but – as importantly – attempts to ensure the quality of service that medical schemes and administrators require from service providers.
The nature of the services provided to NHN members have been made possible by the exemption and include, but are not limited to:
- High-level industry feedback on important and current affairs which gives NHN members insight into industry trends and economic factors which may affect the operation of their hospitals. For example, the NHN managed to facilitate all communication and negotiations between the National Department of Health; the various Provincial Departments of Health; and the private sector co-ordinating committee (B4SA) during the COVID-19 pandemic. This also included co-ordination of the vaccine roll-out to all NHN hospital staff, amounting to over 30 000 people.
- Detailed feedback on ARM arrangements concluded with the medical schemes, and the constitution of these ARMs as to enable facilities to better manage the costs of procedures and to perform procedures profitably.
- Detailed feedback on the tools available to NHN members to assist them in managing their facilities optimally. For example, the Medikredit portal through which it is compulsory for all members to switch their claims provides a platform for data mining on all facilities under the NHN so as to monitor and report on metrics such as admission volumes and revenue, including computation of cost effectiveness metrics through NHN actuaries, the output data of which allows the NHN to negotiate effectively with medical schemes based on the performance of NHN facilities in key cost areas.
- Detailed reports and feedback on cost-efficiency and quality measures in NHN facilities along with recommendations on how to improve such metrics.
- Operational meetings held with medical schemes and/or administrators in which problem areas and/or trends are identified and discussed and approaches to resolve any issues are concluded.
- Regular workshops hosted by the NHN.
- Information manuals provided to the NHN facilities.
- On-site training sessions held at NHN member facilities.
- Newsletters/communiques produced by the NHN for NHN member facilities.
- E-mail and telephonic support which is available to NHN facilities and their staff members.
- The NHN Billing Guide which provides a uniform methodology to NHN members on the management of billing procedures and guidelines.
The NHN understands that medical schemes and medical scheme administrators tend to consider measurables such as quality and efficiencies of NHN members in deciding, inter alia, network appointments, it important for the NHN to ensure competitiveness by assisting members to render services at acceptable standards. The above interventions accordingly support the objectives of the exemption as benchmarking is one of the tools used to achieve the service-delivery requirements of medical schemes and medical scheme administrators.
The NHN has made significant strides in achieving progress on non-price factors under the exemption such as, inter alia, quality of service, efficiency of operations, product information, and access to the market.
The NHN has, at its own cost and at no charge to its members, enabled the generation of reports which members may directly access.
The gains achieved include:
- Implementation of the monthly Hospital Claims Rejection Report which gives member facilities detailed information on claims rejected by medical schemes and medical scheme administrators. The Claims Rejection Report allows members to rectify their claims for reprocessing as well as refine their submission processes to prevent claim rejections in future.
- The NHN implementing the monthly Hospital Generic Utilisation Report which gives NHN member facilities detailed information on the utilization of ‘generic’ drugs as contra-distinguished from the ‘original’ alternative. The utilization of the original product is shown along with the generic alternatives available and the potential cost saving that can be achieved by substituting the original product with the generic alternative. The Hospital Generic Utilisation Report creates awareness where costs can be reduced through generic substitution as to benefit both medical schemes and consumers in a Fee-for-Service environment. Naturally, this enhances the profitability of the facility in a Fixed-Fee environment.
- The implementation of the Hospital Fixed Fee Report gives NHN facilities detailed information on the Fixed Fees generated at a given period, as well as the profit or loss attained against the Fee for Service alternative. Facilities are further provided with a detailed analysis to assist in identifying areas of the Fixed Fees where cost savings can be affected.
- Members having the ability to access the NHN Hospital Efficiency Report which provides detailed information on the services rendered and billed for a given period in a facility. An analysis is performed for several key cost- efficiency and quality metrics and benchmarked against the NHN membership. By creating awareness of where the facility deviates from the norm, the NHN is providing the facility with information which, if acted upon, would probably improve their cost-efficiencies.
Without the intervention and support of the NHN:
- The independent NHN members would not have the skills to provide such analysis and critical input. Individually generating the reports would hardly be worth pursuing as it comes at a great expense. The 3 (three) large hospital groups do not suffer from this disadvantage and use similar information to strengthen and advance their positions.
- The scarcity of the resources required to extract this information suggests that the resources made available by the NHN to its members are not cheap. The skills required are beyond the means and reach of the average NHN facility. In fact, within the 3 (three) large hospital groups, the economies of scale enable these resources to be employed for the greater good and betterment of all their facilities. It would be punitive and economically unsound to expect the NHN facilities to acquire the expertise on an individual basis.
- The actuarial and switching expertise would not be within the financial reach of the average NHN facility. Even if they were, it would be difficult to secure a measure against which the outcomes would be benchmarked as it would be a single facility. The switching of claims through a dedicated switch provides an important mechanism for critical self-reflection on the cost of the services provided by a facility and a means to review such costs to become more cost-effective.
Very recently, the NHN made further strides towards improving non-price factors with the launch of the NHN Dashboard on 23 July 2021. The NHN Dashboard is a new tool which has been carefully crafted to include information that is very beneficial to NHN Members, both in the assessment of quality and cost of care and generates reports of:
- Key schemes and administrators.
- Group level results delineated by hospital.
- Claims metrics including number of admissions and cost per admission which comprise cost buckets and cost drivers such as tariffs, surgicals, ethicals, length of stay, level of care, theatre, etc.
- Quality metrics including admission rates, deaths, pressure ulcers, surgical site infections, surgical site infections, post-surgical venous thrombosis, falls, neonatal injuries, wrong site surgery, retained objects, etc.
- Hospital Efficiency Metrics and benchmarking.
- Contractual obligations to demonstrate monitoring.
On 20 July 2022 the NHN launched its NHN Quality Management Program which empowers its members towards identifying key areas of quality improvement. This will be critical in enabling NHN members engaging in the complex value-based contracting, encouraged by the HMI. The NHN Board formally adopted the NHN Quality Charter in July 2023.
It is through these interventions that most NHN members who ordinarily lacked comparative resources can increase efficiencies and quality of the services that medical schemes and administrators require from service providers.
I welcome you to engage with this directory and allow the information to offer you a glimpse into the expertise, technology, infrastructure, and leading-edge services available at our hospitals.

Neil Nair, CEO

